Wednesday, June 14, 2006

Who's More Activist?

In a recent law review article, Max Huffman reviews Stephen Breyer's Active Liberty and compares it with Antonin Scalia's A Matter of Interpretation. Although Huffman claims the gulf between the two ideologies is not as great as it seems, I believe the ideologies are systematically different in that the former's focuses on the real world outcome of his decision and the latter looks only to the text and history.

Scalia is a well-known Textualist-Originalist, which means he looks for the most reasonable interpretation of the text, and when that is not available, he searches for how reasonable people interpreted the text when it was written and ratified. The practical effects of the decision are mainly irrelevant.

Breyer is more of a pragmatist, or as Huffman puts it, he looks

to ensure that the consequences of the interpretation accord with the purposes of the text.
He focuses on both the text and other real-world considerations, such as how the purpose of the text would interplay with the consequences of his decision. If the purpose of the text is negated by effects of a decision, the pragmatist would render a different decision.

Interestingly, Huffman argues that Scalia is the greater "judicial activist." Defining activist -- or actually using Harriet Mier's definition -- as someone who intends that the judiciary oversee and infringe on the responsibilities of the other coequal branches, he states:

The undisguised import of Justice Scalia’s discussion of legislative history is that by ignoring it, the Court hopefully will cause Congress to stop creating it and instead legislate in some more appropriate fashion. If any judicial endeavor is susceptible to being labeled “problem solution” or “oversight,” it is that one. Justice Breyer’s stated goal of determining the purposes of the text being interpreted and considering whether the consequences of a particular interpretation, meet those purposes, must be thought the less activist approach.
I would define activism differently. A judge whose ideology makes it likely that his decisions will overstep the bounds of the court is an activist. Now obviously that definition begs the question of what decision is out of bounds. But I think we could all agree that some decisions are unreasonable and out of bounds. Those decisions are generally cases where the judge decided to act as a legislator. Textualist-Originalist decisions are less likely to be unreasonable because Textualism-Originalism provides a guidepost to review judges and therefore makes it less probable that they would decide cases as legislators. Originalism's greatest quality is objectivity, which mitigates activism.

Huffman's article is worth a read, especially if you have read either Scalia's or Breyer's book.

6 Comments:

Blogger Charlie Hall said...

'Originalism's greatest quality is objectivity, which mitigates activism'

I disagree. It has been a long time since most of the Constitution was written and interpretations have changed with the times.

For example, an originalist interpretation of the establishment clause would reverse decades of precendent in applying it to the states. It is clear that Jefferson and Madison did not understand it as applying to the states, as all of New England except Rhode Island maintained their established churches into the 19th century. (Rhode Island never HAD an established church.) But OTOH it would accept the broad application to the federal government that the ACLU supports; much of the current government support to religious institutions would be held invalid. Both of these should be considered activist positions today. I'm working on my own post on this very point.

Even more radical would be to void the kind of executive branch legislating that takes place via regulations. The Supreme Court indeed took a dim view of this during the first five years of the New Deal, until Roosevelt was able to appoint justices who realized that Congress just couldn't write sufficiently detailed legislation to cover every contingency. The Administrative Procedures Act codified this into law in 1946:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Administrative_Procedure_Act

No true originalist would permit such, as the founding fathers never imagined an executive branch agency essentially making law -- but the chaos that would result from voiding thousands of federal regulations that have the force of law would mean near anarchy. Justice Breyer's consideration of such effects definitely has the edge as a practical, conservative method of jurisprudence.

6/14/2006 11:21 PM  
Blogger Nephtuli said...

Well, we're defining activism differently apparently. I don't disagree that a strict interpretation of originalism would erase decades of precedent. Of course in reality no judge actually calls for that, as even Thomas allows precedent to trump the original understanding in some cases.

And Breyer's jurisprudence is certainly more practical from that perspective, but that's not the point. Originalism is not supposed to be pragmatic; that's its draw.

6/15/2006 12:17 AM  
Blogger ninest123 said...

longchamp outlet, louboutin outlet, louboutin, polo ralph lauren outlet, nike air max, ray ban sunglasses, cheap oakley sunglasses, oakley sunglasses, burberry, gucci outlet, michael kors, nike roshe run, tiffany jewelry, jordan shoes, replica watches, longchamp pas cher, louis vuitton outlet, ray ban sunglasses, louis vuitton, replica watches, nike outlet, uggs on sale, louboutin pas cher, ugg boots, ray ban sunglasses, prada outlet, prada handbags, oakley sunglasses, tiffany and co, sac longchamp, nike free, oakley sunglasses, louis vuitton, ugg boots, air max, kate spade outlet, louis vuitton outlet, longchamp, louis vuitton, nike free, nike air max, air jordan pas cher, christian louboutin outlet, chanel handbags, oakley sunglasses, tory burch outlet, polo ralph lauren outlet, ralph lauren pas cher, longchamp outlet, louboutin shoes

7/23/2016 8:02 PM  
Blogger ninest123 said...

sac guess, hollister pas cher, michael kors, michael kors, vanessa bruno, michael kors outlet, nike blazer, michael kors outlet, michael kors outlet, nike air max, air force, michael kors outlet, ray ban pas cher, converse pas cher, coach purses, michael kors, lululemon, abercrombie and fitch, true religion jeans, true religion outlet, ray ban uk, hollister, vans pas cher, north face, new balance pas cher, hermes, replica handbags, coach outlet, kate spade handbags, michael kors outlet, oakley pas cher, nike free run uk, michael kors, nike air max, nike roshe, lacoste pas cher, ugg boots, true religion jeans, north face, ralph lauren uk, tn pas cher, burberry outlet online, hogan, ugg boots, true religion jeans, nike air max, burberry, timberland, mulberry, coach outlet

7/23/2016 8:05 PM  
Blogger ninest123 said...

mcm handbags, timberland boots, louboutin, hollister, hollister, jimmy choo shoes, lululemon, reebok shoes, giuseppe zanotti, asics running shoes, herve leger, oakley, bottega veneta, mac cosmetics, iphone cases, p90x workout, vans, north face outlet, valentino shoes, chi flat iron, ray ban, soccer jerseys, nike trainers, celine handbags, ghd, nike air max, north face outlet, new balance, converse outlet, gucci, ralph lauren, nike air max, lancel, longchamp, nike roshe, instyler, vans shoes, nfl jerseys, birkin bag, soccer shoes, baseball bats, babyliss, hollister, beats by dre, ferragamo shoes, wedding dresses, abercrombie and fitch, nike huarache, mont blanc, insanity workout

7/23/2016 8:08 PM  
Blogger ninest123 said...

montre pas cher, swarovski crystal, wedding dresses, louis vuitton, canada goose, moncler, canada goose uk, pandora charms, ugg,uggs,uggs canada, ugg pas cher, replica watches, swarovski, canada goose, moncler, moncler, thomas sabo, marc jacobs, bottes ugg, canada goose outlet, canada goose outlet, pandora jewelry, coach outlet, links of london, karen millen, moncler, toms shoes, supra shoes, louis vuitton, pandora charms, moncler, doudoune canada goose, louis vuitton, juicy couture outlet, pandora jewelry, canada goose, sac louis vuitton pas cher, louis vuitton, ugg,ugg australia,ugg italia, canada goose, moncler outlet, juicy couture outlet, hollister, moncler, ugg boots uk, moncler

7/23/2016 8:11 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home